A Guide to Car Rental for Young Drivers in the US
You are 21 to 24 years old, you have landed in New York, and you need a car. Contrary to popular myth, renting a car at this age is completely legal.
However, the rental market is tough on young drivers: hidden fees, counter rejections, and geographic penalties. Below is a guide on how to secure a car, save your sanity, and avoid overpaying by using Drivo.
Location strategy: why New Jersey beats New York
Your age affects insurance costs. The rental location determines the size of that impact.
- New York (JFK) legally requires rentals to drivers 18+, but at a price. Daily surcharges for ages 21–24 reach $30–35; for 18–20 year-olds, expect $64–84 per day.
- New Jersey (EWR) operates under market competition rather than legal mandate. Daily surcharges for ages 21–24 average $25, and overall insurance costs are $10–20 per day versus $15–30 in New York. Competing companies keep prices realistic.
- The Solution: Drivo is based in Newark (EWR) to leverage this competitive advantage. By renting here, you avoid the New York "geography tax" and access transparent pricing. Over a week-long rental, this saves you $35–70 on surcharges alone.
The cost: Young Driver Fee
You will see a line item on your receipt: Young Driver Fee. This is not a fine, but insurance mathematics: statistics show higher accident rates for drivers under 25.
- Cost: An additional $25–35 per day ($175–245 per week).
- The Drivo advantage: We use a transparent fixed rate. You see the final total on the website before you book. No surprise "administrative fees" at the counter. You can budget to the exact dollar.
How to rent without a credit card
Major rental companies require a credit card to block a security deposit. If you only have a debit card, Drivo will accept it under three security conditions.
1. Card in your name
The name on the bank card must match the name on your driver’s license. Cards belonging to parents or friends are not accepted. This is a matter of legal liability.
2. Return ticket
We need confirmation that you will be leaving. A PDF, screenshot, or email from the airline with your arrival and departure dates will suffice.
3. Increased deposit
When paying with a debit card, the insurance risk is higher.
- Deposit: $300–500 higher than the standard amount.
- Refund: The amount is unblocked and returned to your account within 3–5 days after the car is returned.
Car selection: available classes
Insurance restricts the choice of vehicles for drivers aged 21–24. Premium cars, large SUVs, and full-size sedans are unavailable to you.
| Model | Main Benefit | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Chevrolet Spark | Price | Solo travel and strict budgeting. Fuel consumption is minimal. Trunk space is modest (310 L). |
| Hyundai Accent | Parking | Trips around Brooklyn or Queens. The 4.5m length allows you to park where others won't fit. |
| Hyundai Elantra | Comfort | Long trips (2+ hours) with friends. Apple CarPlay, soft suspension, full-size trunk. |
Important: Do not try to book a higher class (e.g., Nissan Altima). You will be refused at the counter and offered a lower class. Save time — book what is available.
Rules of the road: where you can and cannot drive
The cars are equipped with GPS. This is a contract protection tool.
- Allowed Zone: New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania.
- Prohibited Zone: Any other state.
- Consequences: Crossing a border (e.g., entering Maryland) is logged automatically. This results in a fine and a breach of the rental contract.
Tip: Check your route on Google Maps in advance. If the entire path lies within these four states, you are safe.
Travel expenses: tolls and parking
Tolls
Roads in the Northeast are expensive. A one-way trip through the Holland Tunnel or Lincoln Tunnel costs $14–18. A round trip to Philadelphia will cost ~$100–140.
How to Save:
Ask for an E-ZPass transponder when picking up your car at Drivo.
- You save 15–20% on toll costs.
- You avoid administrative fines for unpaid tolls (toll-by-plate) that arrive a month later.
Parking in New York City
If you are going to see Manhattan, leave the car behind.
- Overnight garage: $30–40.
- Weekly MetroCard (subway): $33.
The car is for trips out of the city (Hamptons, Catskills, Jersey Shore). If you are staying in the city overnight, look for parking in Brooklyn or Queens—it is half the price of Manhattan.
Safety checklist: how not to lose money
- Second Driver: If a friend takes the wheel, add them to the contract ($15–25/day). If they get into an accident without being listed, all financial liability ($50,000+) falls on you.
- Photo Evidence: Take photos of the car from all angles, including the interior and fuel level, at pickup. This is your insurance against claims for old scratches.
- Full Tank: Return the car with a full tank. Refueling at the rental agency costs $7–8 per liter vs. $3.50 at a gas station. 10 minutes at the pump will save you ~$100.
- International Driving Permit (IDP): If your license was issued outside the US (e.g., Russia, EU), an International Driving Permit is mandatory. Without it, rental will be refused.
Ready to hit the road?
- Book a car: drivo.com
- Call to confirm details: (855) 550-0008 (Mon–Tue: 06:00 AM – Midnight)
- Arrive: 408 Carnegie Ave, Ste 408, Newark, NJ 07114
Drivo makes renting accessible, transparent, and safe. Book now and start your journey.
tips, straight to your inbox
