How to choose a car for winter rentals in New York City
Winter in New York City isn’t extreme, but it is unpredictable. Roads may stay wet all day, freeze overnight, and turn icy again by morning. Temperatures usually hover around freezing, and black ice appears quickly — especially on bridges, elevated roads, and near the water.
That’s why choosing the right rental car matters not just for comfort, but for safety and confidence behind the wheel.
If you’re staying within the city
For driving in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, or other NYC neighborhoods, you don’t need a large SUV to stay safe. Front-wheel-drive sedans and compact SUVs handle typical winter conditions very well. They’re easier to park, more fuel-efficient, and fully capable on wet roads, light snow, and occasional ice.
All-season M+S tires are generally enough for city driving — as long as they’re in good condition. Tread depth and tire grip matter far more than engine size or power.
Leaving the city? Conditions change
The situation changes if you’re driving north — to the Hudson Valley, Catskills, Adirondacks, or Upstate ski towns. Expect lower temperatures, more frequent snowfall, and icy hills and curves.
For these trips, it’s smart to choose:
- AWD or 4WD
- Higher ground clearance
- If possible, 3PMSF-rated winter tires for maximum grip on snow and ice
What New York State Law says
New York State does not require drivers to use winter tires — even in winter. However, during snow emergencies, some roads may issue winter tire advisories.
If you’re driving into snowy areas, always check with your rental company before you go:
- What tires are installed?
- Are winter tires available?
- Are there any road-specific requirements for your route?
At Drivo, you can confirm tire type and drivetrain before booking.
The real winter safety feature: tires
It’s easy to assume that AWD is what makes a car winter-ready — but AWD only helps you move forward. Your tires are what help you stop and stay in control.
What to look for:
- M+S (Mud & Snow) — good for most NYC winters
- 3PMSF — best for frequent snow and colder climates
- Deep tread, even wear, flexible rubber
What to сheck in a rental car
Before you drive away, take a minute to look at:
- Windshield washer fluid: winter-grade, won’t freeze (usually blue)
- Tires: good tread depth, M+S or 3PMSF marking, no visible damage
- Winter tools: scraper and snow brush onboard
- Electronics: defrosters, heating, ABS, traction control are working
These small checks make a big difference on winter roads.
Which car type to choose
- For city driving: FWD sedan or compact SUV — easy to handle, efficient, winter-ready with M+S tires.
- For winter road trips: AWD SUV with higher clearance + space for gear.
- For family travel: stable braking, good visibility, reliable heating, extra cargo capacity.
Conclusion
Winter in New York can feel unpredictable — but with the right tires, the right drivetrain, and a quick check before you hit the road, it becomes easy to navigate and even fun to explore.
And if you're renting with Drivo, we’re always here to help — whether you’re unsure about tire markings, planning a snowy road trip, or just want the safest option available.
tips, straight to your inbox
